Part 12 - Burnham Facing Reality In The Era of The Gamblers, (4) Tilting At Windmills (Continued)
The revision of history in the period after 2015, claims that Corbyn, reflecting his past anti-EU, position, failed to actively campaign for Remain. That, as set out above, was false. What was true is that he did not fawn over the EU, ignoring its neo-liberal nature, as though it alone could be the answer to workers' problems, which clearly it could not, any more than leaving the neo-liberal EU, for the equally neo-liberal UK, was any solution for workers' problems. In fact, the whole foundation of the petty-bourgeois nationalist Leave campaign, led by the likes of Farage, Mogg, Bojo et al, was that, outside the EU, a reactionary-nationalist government would be able to remove all of the protections that workers in Britain enjoyed, not to mention all of those regulations that set minimum standards for the protection of consumers, the environment ad so on.
As Marx set out in Wage-Labour & Capital, so long as capitalism exists, the best conditions for workers are those in which capital expands, because its in those conditions that the demand for labour-power rises, and so workers can sell their labour-power at higher prices. But, Marx explains, the fact these are the best conditions for workers, so long as capitalism exists, does not mean that they are the best conditions for workers. As I have set out elsewhere, Marx explains how these best conditions for workers under capitalism, simply lead to a crisis of overproduction of capital relative to labour. As relative wages rise, and relative profits fall, the least efficient firms make losses, and go out of business, throwing their workers on to the street. Those workers now suffer a sharp fall in their incomes, they cannot spend, and so their demand for other wage goods drops. In addition, the firm itself, now, does not exist to buy its materials, machines and so on, and so its suppliers see a big drop in demand for their output.
What was an overproduction of capital relative to labour supply, now becomes a generalised overproduction of commodities, because firms that previously were profitable, seeing a sharp drop in demand for their output, are faced with a need to reduce their market prices in order to clear the surplus, and that drop in prices, in turn, means that for many of them, they sell at a loss. Some of them, also, now go bust, or at least reduce output, and lay off workers, causing the overproduction to spread throughout the economy.
In addition, the solution to the overproduction of capital, relative to labour, is resolved as firms engage, at last, in widespread technological innovation, so that machines/technology replaces labour, and a relative surplus population is created. What was the best condition for workers, within capitalism, simply turns inextricably and inevitably into a crisis for capital, which, in turn creates a crisis for labour. And, the same applies in relation to the EU, as a much bigger capital, compared to the UK, as a much smaller, and declining capital.
But, as Marx notes, the fact that the best conditions for workers within the context of capitalism, always turn into the worst conditions for workers, does not change the fact that we should encourage those best conditions, and take advantage of them, so as to build the strength and organisation of the labour movement. It just means that socialists have a duty to provide the political leadership that explains that those conditions are temporary, and that the solution resides in dealing with that property question, the question of who controls the large-scale, socialised industrial capital. In the end, that property question itself requires that control to be exercised in such a way that the workers understand the need to transform their collective capital, into being simply means of production. To utilise it, rather than it utilising them.
Social-democracy cannot do that. Progressive social-democracy reflecting the interests of the actual socialised, industrial capital, refracted through the lens of the large army of day to day, professional managers, found its limits, at least for that cycle, in the 1970's. It promoted the corresponding ideas of corporatism, planning and regulation. It created national economic planning bodies where they did not exist, such as NEDO, in Britain, and also, began the process of industrial democracy, as with the Bullock Report in Britain, the EU's Draft Fifth Company Law Directive, and so on, which continued the ideas of co-determination, as already existed in Germany. But, it was the fact that this came at the point in the cycle where a crisis of overproduction of capital existed that meant, all of these developments were reversed.
Workers needed to break out of the constraints of capital, to resolve that crisis, but their political leadership did not even understand the nature of the problem, as set out earlier. Indeed, recognising the nature of these corporatist proposals, many on the Left simply opposed them, preferring instead to argue for workers to continue their old, doomed struggle for higher wages, or for the capitalist state to come to their rescue, by nationalisation, the consequences of which have been discussed and seen in relation to the use of those nationalised industries in coal, steel, shipbuilding and so on, as the point of the spear of capital, to break the labour movement. Progressive social democracy reached its limits, and could not go beyond it. And, much like the defeat of the revolutions of 1848, although conservative social-democracy, took the helm, it too was led into creating the conditions n which, social-democracy itself, was undermined, as a growing petty-bourgeois mass asserted itself, and demanded the clock be rolled back to the days of the early 19th century.
No comments:
Post a Comment