Monday, 16 November 2026

Burnham's Dead Cat Bounce - Part 10 - Burnham Facing Reality In The Era of The Gamblers, (2) Betting On Growth

Part 10 - Burnham Facing Reality In The Era of The Gamblers, (2) Betting On Growth


Burnham, like Starmer, has placed his bets on growth resolving his problems, a bit like a desperate person seeking the solution to their problems by endlessly buying scratch cards. The problem is that neither Starmer nor Burnham seem to connect the dots that growth is not something that simply happens, or can be called into existence just because it is a convenient solution for the economy's problems at any given time. Or, more correctly, as Marx noted, in relation to the the arguments of Ricardo, growth does occur naturally, as a consequence of population growth, which expands the market, which means that businesses bank on such expansion, and the increased population, also, provides them with the additional labour required to grow the capital, but its not the solution.

“The demand increases constantly, and, in anticipation of this new capital is continually invested in new land, although this varies with the circumstances for different agricultural products. It is the formation of new capitals which in itself brings this about. But so far as the individual capitalist is concerned, he measures the volume of his production by that of his available capital, to the extent that he can still control it himself. His aim is to capture as big a portion as possible of the market. Should there be any over-production, he will not take the blame upon himself, but places it upon his competitors.”

(Capital III, Chapter 39)

So, this form of growth, naturally occurring growth due to population growth, leads to a rise in GDP (National Income), because more labour is employed, more new value is created, and this new value divides into wages and industrial profit, the latter then being divided into interest/dividends, rent, taxes and profit of enterprise/retained profit. But, it does not magically solve the problems of the economy, and certainly not the problems of the British economy currently, nor the problems of financing government spending. The most obvious reason for that is that this growth of GDP, i.e. the rise in the total mass of incomes/new value created, is not the same thing as a rise in the per capita GDP, i.e. the income/new value created, per head of population.

On the contrary, a rise in the mass of incomes/GDP, may result in a fall in income per capita, if the consequence of the additional employment is lower productivity. One of the biggest problems of the UK economy since the 1980's, has been precisely its poor productivity, and one of the reasons for that is that deindustrialisation, and the corresponding growth of the petty-bourgeoisie/self-employed, meant that large numbers of people were engaged in labour that was grossly inefficient. It more or less returned them to the kinds of levels of productivity of the self-sufficient peasant or independent commodity producer. Its why the existence of such labour is so precarious, and can only continue on the basis of very low living standards compared to that of wage-workers, for those engaged in it. Indeed, were it not for the fact that productivity in the rest of the economy has risen significantly, so that the unit value of commodities has fallen (so the amount everyone, including the petty-bourgeois/self-employed have to pay for them, be it to live or to produce) the standard of living of the petty-bourgeois – their real incomes – would have fallen catastrophically.

A large part of the rise in the productivity in the rest of the economy, and fall in the unit value of commodities was, itself, a consequence of the globalisation that occurred from the 1980's onwards, and, of course, of the reduction in trade frictions etc., that came from membership of the EU. But, it can be seen that many of those factors have been brought to a halt or even reversed as a result of Brexit, and that Brexit, advocated by Starmer and Blue Labour, precisely to assuage those same petty-bourgeois voters, is also still not being wholeheartedly challenged by Burnham. There is no solution based on growth without reversing Brexit, and the idea that there is some kind of Burnham Brexit, Labour Brexit or better relation with the EU that does not involve re-joining the EU is simply fantasy – the same fantasy that has been pursued for the last decade and more. The statement of Burnham, last week, that he intends to negotiate a deal with the EU that would bring the kind of Brexit that people voted for in 2016, is total nonsense, and indicates why his bounce in the polls will not last.

No comments: