Wednesday, 18 November 2026

Burnham's Dead Cat Bounce - Part 11- Burnham Facing Reality In The Era of The Gamblers, (3) Tilting At Windmills

Part 11- Burnham Facing Reality In The Era of The Gamblers, (3) Tilting At Windmills

What does Burnham mean when he says that he wants to negotiate a deal with the EU that would give voters the Brexit they voted for? James O'Brien constantly challenges those who support/ed Brexit to spell out exactly what Brexit it was they voted for, and, of course, most of them cannot give an answer, and those that do, simply show that the reason one person voted for it, is not the same as that of others who voted for it. The idea that the debate is being “reopened” is, of course, nonsense, because no one has ever stopped discussing it for the last ten years, and could not have done otherwise, because each day that goes by shows how ludicrous it was, and why it needs to be reversed.


For Burnham to talk about negotiating the Brexit that people voted for is, then, multiply, nonsense because even those that voted for Brexit have any number of different visions of what they thought they were voting for. And, as I pointed out at the time, and as has become obvious since, whatever vision of Brexit they had, none of them was ever going to happen, because they were, and are, impossible. Many of them were not even voting, in that referendum, solely on the question of Brexit or the EU. They were using it to vote against Cameron/Osborn and their policies of austerity, implemented with the aid of the Liberals, after 2010. Many, more were simply using it as a proxy for stopping immigration, and a large part of them, for also expressing their deep-seated racism and bigotry, not just limited to stopping immigration, but also seeking the “repatriation” of “migrants”, by which they really meant, anyone who was not white.

So, exactly which of those reactionary visions of Brexit, does Burnham think that he is going to champion? But, more importantly, in 2015, when Corbyn became Labour Leader, with the help of around 250,000+ new, young, pro-EU members, he was forced by that reality, in 2016, to suppress his own long-standing economic-nationalist ideology, and ride the wave of that, pro-EU movement. In 2016, despite the revision of history, Corbyn did go out and do lots of events promoting Labour's pro-Remain position. The media, of course, did not report it, because they wanted to deny him and Labour any publicity, and were more interested in the kitchen sink drama going on in the Conservative Party between Cameron and Bojo, Gove et al, not to mention that surrounding the likes of Farage that the media had feted uncritically for the previous 20 years, as it transformed news reporting into simply sensationalised entertainment, and cult of celebrity.

Corbyn's weakness, in 2016, which was manifest later, was not that he allowed his, old, anti-EEC, economic-nationalist agenda to win out, but that he tried to cosy-up to the Blair-Right wing of the Labour Party, as it sought to undermine him at every step, and remove him. The Labour Right have always understood the concept of revolutionary defeatism when it comes to their fight against the Left in the Party, even if it results in the defeat of Labour at the polls. They put their class loyalty to the ruling-class above their loyalty to the party, every time. Just look at the role of the SDP, for example. Corbyn, in trying to accommodate the Labour Right, appointed Blair-Right former Minister, Alan Johnson, to head up Labour's Referendum campaign. Johnson who the media were promoting as a future Labour Leader, able to walk on water, of course, promptly disappeared from sight during the referendum campaign.

Corbyn was, of course, right not to give the neo-liberal EU 10/10 when asked, although it was clearly a trap, and his high positive score of 7/10 has been used against him, afterwards as supposedly some indication of how his old position affected his role during the campaign. Alan Johnson, who was supposed to lead Labour's campaign, but who was like a ghost through it all, showed his face afterwards, of course, to blame it on Corbyn!  But, the facts show different. During 2016, Labour continued to attract large numbers of those new, young, pro-EU members, and millions more of them as voters.


The polling done by John Curtice and others shows that, the percentage of those that voted Labour under Ed Miliband, in 2015, who voted Remain, was around 65%. But, the percentage of those that voted Labour, under Corbyn, in 2017, who voted Remain, in 2016, is much higher. It is estimated at between 70-74%.

Key Estimates by Source
  • British Election Study (BES). Wave 16 of the British Election Study (collected between 24 May and 18 June 2019 from a sample of 37,959 respondents) found that 68% of 2017 Labour voters voted to Remain in 2016.

  • House of Commons Library. An analysis published by the House of Commons Library on 23 June 2017 reported that 71% of 2017 Labour voters voted Remain, while 29% voted Leave.

  • YouGov. Survey data from YouGov, cited in a BBC News report on 29 April 2019, estimated that 29% of 2017 Labour voters who participated in the referendum voted Leave, placing the Remain share at 71%.

  • ComRes. Estimates from ComRes, also cited by BBC News on 29 April 2019, found that 26% of 2017 Labour voters backed Leave in 2016, implying that up to 74% voted Remain or did not vote in the referendum.
Breakdown by Constituency Type
  • According to the British Election Study findings published on 17 October 2019, a majority of 2017 Labour voters backed Remain across all types of constituencies:

  • Remain-voting constituencies. In Labour-held seats that voted Remain in 2016, 76% of 2017 Labour voters had voted Remain.

  • Leave-voting constituencies. In Labour-held seats that voted Leave in 2016, 60% of 2017 Labour voters had voted Remain.

  • Strongly Leave-voting constituencies. Even in seats where the overall Leave vote exceeded 60%, 57% of 2017 Labour voters had voted Remain.
In other words, Corbyn's Labour in 2017, not only won over large numbers of voters in total, compared to 2015 under Ed Miliband, and not only secured 40% of the vote, it also won over a large number of those Remainers that had voted for other parties, in 2015, i.e. primarily Liberals, Greens, Plaid and SNP. So, when Burnham talks about negotiating a Brexit deal of the kind that people voted for in 2016, what about that large majority, between 70-74% of Labour voters, who in 2016, did not vote for Brexit at all! Why does he, like Starmer continue to ignore us, and instead continues to engage in a Quixotic endeavour to win over the votes of the reactionary petty-bourgeoisie?

Monday, 16 November 2026

Burnham's Dead Cat Bounce - Part 10 - Burnham Facing Reality In The Era of The Gamblers, (2) Betting On Growth

Part 10 - Burnham Facing Reality In The Era of The Gamblers, (2) Betting On Growth


Burnham, like Starmer, has placed his bets on growth resolving his problems, a bit like a desperate person seeking the solution to their problems by endlessly buying scratch cards. The problem is that neither Starmer nor Burnham seem to connect the dots that growth is not something that simply happens, or can be called into existence just because it is a convenient solution for the economy's problems at any given time. Or, more correctly, as Marx noted, in relation to the the arguments of Ricardo, growth does occur naturally, as a consequence of population growth, which expands the market, which means that businesses bank on such expansion, and the increased population, also, provides them with the additional labour required to grow the capital, but its not the solution.

“The demand increases constantly, and, in anticipation of this new capital is continually invested in new land, although this varies with the circumstances for different agricultural products. It is the formation of new capitals which in itself brings this about. But so far as the individual capitalist is concerned, he measures the volume of his production by that of his available capital, to the extent that he can still control it himself. His aim is to capture as big a portion as possible of the market. Should there be any over-production, he will not take the blame upon himself, but places it upon his competitors.”

(Capital III, Chapter 39)

So, this form of growth, naturally occurring growth due to population growth, leads to a rise in GDP (National Income), because more labour is employed, more new value is created, and this new value divides into wages and industrial profit, the latter then being divided into interest/dividends, rent, taxes and profit of enterprise/retained profit. But, it does not magically solve the problems of the economy, and certainly not the problems of the British economy currently, nor the problems of financing government spending. The most obvious reason for that is that this growth of GDP, i.e. the rise in the total mass of incomes/new value created, is not the same thing as a rise in the per capita GDP, i.e. the income/new value created, per head of population.

On the contrary, a rise in the mass of incomes/GDP, may result in a fall in income per capita, if the consequence of the additional employment is lower productivity. One of the biggest problems of the UK economy since the 1980's, has been precisely its poor productivity, and one of the reasons for that is that deindustrialisation, and the corresponding growth of the petty-bourgeoisie/self-employed, meant that large numbers of people were engaged in labour that was grossly inefficient. It more or less returned them to the kinds of levels of productivity of the self-sufficient peasant or independent commodity producer. Its why the existence of such labour is so precarious, and can only continue on the basis of very low living standards compared to that of wage-workers, for those engaged in it. Indeed, were it not for the fact that productivity in the rest of the economy has risen significantly, so that the unit value of commodities has fallen (so the amount everyone, including the petty-bourgeois/self-employed have to pay for them, be it to live or to produce) the standard of living of the petty-bourgeois – their real incomes – would have fallen catastrophically.

A large part of the rise in the productivity in the rest of the economy, and fall in the unit value of commodities was, itself, a consequence of the globalisation that occurred from the 1980's onwards, and, of course, of the reduction in trade frictions etc., that came from membership of the EU. But, it can be seen that many of those factors have been brought to a halt or even reversed as a result of Brexit, and that Brexit, advocated by Starmer and Blue Labour, precisely to assuage those same petty-bourgeois voters, is also still not being wholeheartedly challenged by Burnham. There is no solution based on growth without reversing Brexit, and the idea that there is some kind of Burnham Brexit, Labour Brexit or better relation with the EU that does not involve re-joining the EU is simply fantasy – the same fantasy that has been pursued for the last decade and more. The statement of Burnham, last week, that he intends to negotiate a deal with the EU that would bring the kind of Brexit that people voted for in 2016, is total nonsense, and indicates why his bounce in the polls will not last.


Sunday, 15 November 2026

Anti-Duhring, Part III – Socialism, II – Theoretical - Part 33

At a time when the scale of production had burst through the fetters of the nation state, and required the creation of ever larger multinational states, this petty-bourgeois reaction demanded Brexit border controls, and when that inevitably, also, failed that reactionary dynamic meant an even greater historical reversion, leading to demands to break up even existing nation states.

The chickens of the petty-bourgeois, nationalist and Sismondist ideology of “the Left” came home to roost with a vengeance, but it has remained unable to free itself from that ideology. Engels, also, notes that there was nothing inherently socialist about the demand for nationalisation by the capitalist state. It was simply that at a certain point in the scale and development of socialised capital, it becomes inevitable, and only on that basis progressive.

“I say is constrained to. For it is only when the means of production or communication have actually outgrown direction by joint-stock companies, and, therefore, their nationalization has become economically inevitable — it is only then that this nationalization, even when carried out by the state of today — represents an economic advance, the attainment of another preliminary step towards the seizure of all the productive forces by society itself. But, since Bismarck became keen on nationalizing, a certain spurious socialism has recently made its appearance – here and there even degenerating into a kind of flunkeyism - that without more ado declares all nationalization, even the Bismarckian kind, to be socialistic. To be sure, if the nationalization of the tobacco trade were socialistic, Napoleon and Metternich would rank among the founders of socialism. If the Belgian state, for quite ordinary political and financial reasons, constructed its own main railway lines, if Bismarck, without any economic compulsion, nationalized the main Prussian railway lines simply in order to be the better able to organize and use them in face of war, in order to train the railway officials as the government's voting cattle, and especially in order to secure a new source of revenue independent of parliamentary votes, such actions were in no sense socialistic measures, whether direct or indirect, conscious or unconscious. Otherwise, the Royal Maritime Company, the Royal Porcelain Manufacture, and even the regimental tailors of the army would also be socialistic institutions [or even, as was seriously proposed by a sly dog in the thirties during the reign of Frederick William III, the nationalization of the brothels].” (Note *, p 359)

In the 1980's, for all those that had forgotten this ABC of Marxism, they were given a sharp reminder. As capital was overproduced, relative to labour supply, relative wages rose, relative profits fell. Rather than being the vehicle by which this crisis led to a rational solution, based on a transition to Socialism, the capitalist state, and the nationalised industries it controlled, became the main weapon in attacking the working-class. The bosses of those nationalised industries, appointed by the capitalist state, as their sole shareholders, were, of course, the same bosses who the day before, and the day after, were the bosses of the large corporations. In Britain, Michael Edwards at British Leyland, Iain McGregor at the National Coal Board, and so on, used the full force of the capitalist state, both its financial might, and its armed might, to defeat the strikes of the workers whose collective property they insisted be controlled by the state.

“If the crises revealed the bourgeoisie's incapacity to continue to administer the modern productive forces, the conversion of the large production and communication establishments into joint-stock companies [trusts] and state property shows that the bourgeoisie can be dispensed with for this purpose. All the social functions of the capitalist are now conducted by salaried employees. The capitalist no longer has any social activity save the pocketing of revenues, the clipping of coupons, and gambling on the Stock Exchange, where the different capitalists fleece each other of their capital. Just as at first the capitalist mode of production displaced the workers, so, now it is displacing the capitalists, relegating them, just as it did the workers, to the superfluous population, although not immediately to the industrial reserve army.” (p 359-60)

Friday, 13 November 2026

Burnham's Dead Cat Bounce - Part 9 - Burnham Facing Reality In The Era of The Gamblers, (1) When The Chips Are Down

Part 9 - Burnham Facing Reality In The Era of The Gamblers, (1) When The Chips Are Down


In the last few days, the news has been full of reports of the fall in the price of Nvidia shares, much of which has centred around the sexual affairs of its CEO, Jensen Huang. The CEO sits atop that pyramid of Directors, appointed by shareholders, to represent their interests, as against the company interest, by maximising shareholder value. So, its no wonder that the news reports, representing, themselves, the interests and views – the ruling ideas of the age – of that ruling class of speculators/gamblers, have expressed alarm at the fall in the price of the shares, especially as it ties into a renewed concern about the likelihood of astronomically inflated asset prices facing another crash, centred around a few large tech stocks, and chip makers like Nvidia.

But, those news reports, also, have presented the fall in the share price of Nvidia as being a fall in the value of the company itself. In other words, the idea that it is fictitious-capital that is “real capital”, whereas the actual real capital, the industrial capital which produces surplus-value and profits, is simply a collection of things to be managed. That is not true, as Marx set out long ago. Its not the company that has lost money or value, as a result of the fall in its share price. It has exactly the same money in its bank account it had before. The value of the components of its industrial capital – the buildings, machines, materials, and workforce – are completely unchanged.

The losers are only the shareholders, whose shares, if they sold them, would be worth less. It is only their inflated paper wealth that has been reduced, not the value of the company. Indeed, whilst the existing shareholders would lose out, if they sold their shares, today, the new buyers of those shares would, equally, be the beneficiaries. If the bank that loaned you money to buy your house, went bust, it would not change the value of your house, or its use-value. Another lender would buy up its business on the cheap, and you would just pay your mortgage payments to them.

As Marx put it,

“As regards the fall in the purely nominal capital, State bonds, shares etc.—in so far as it does not lead to the bankruptcy of the state or of the share company, or to the complete stoppage of reproduction through undermining the credit of the industrial capitalists who hold such securities—it amounts only to the transfer of wealth from one hand to another and will, on the whole, act favourably upon reproduction, since the parvenus into whose hands these stocks or shares fall cheaply, are mostly more enterprising than their former owners.”

(Theories Of Surplus Value, Part 2, p 496)

Its only insofar as companies, also, buy the shares of other companies that a fall in share prices would affect them, as a shareholder, like any other. If the current share price of company A, drops by 50%, then, if it seeks to raise additional money-capital, via a share issue, it would have to issue twice as many shares, compared to prior to the fall, to raise any given amount of money. If the amount of dividend per share remained the same that would be equal to a doubling of the yield on those additional shares. It sums up the delicious nature of the problems of the ruling-class of gamblers/coupon clippers, and of conservative social-democracy as their representative, in seeking to both have their cake and eat it.

On the one hand, they want to have higher yields on their financial and property assets, but, now, those higher yields can only come from a fall in the price of their assets, i.e. share, bond and property market crashes, upon which their whole paper wealth, and the ideology of conservative social-democracy (neoliberalism) has been built in the last 40 years.


Thursday, 12 November 2026

Anti-Duhring, Part III – Socialism, II – Theoretical - Part 32

As I predicted would happen, the surge in liquidity created during lockdowns – precisely at a time when output was deliberately and administratively reduced as government policy, and so where less currency should have been thrown into circulation – led to the high levels of commodity price inflation that occurred when lockdowns were ended, and so those depreciated money tokens flooded into the market. So, the idea that the government could just print money tokens, and, then, spend them has numerous problems.

Firstly, it depends what the government spends those money tokens on. It is only if it spends them on things that actually create new value, and which, then contribute to the economy via exchange that it would increase growth, rather than just be inflationary. Military, spending, for example, would just be inflationary. Spending on welfare benefits would similarly be inflationary.

But, as noted earlier, even if the government could direct these money tokens into value creating activity, for example, repairing crumbling roads, which can be accomplished quickly, it would take around 18-24 months before this becomes manifest, and during all that time, the government would face attack from the capitalist media, pointing to a falling Pound, rising interest rates and prices, and falling stock, bond and property markets.

If, however, the working-class, collectively, controlled the money in its pension funds, some of that could be avoided. The working-class could directly fund capital accumulation in cooperative production. Directly elected supervisory boards of workers, controlling their own pension funds, would make long-term decisions based on heir own interests for employment and economic security, rather than the short-term interest of the ruling-class speculators in inflating asset prices.

For that very reason, the ruling-class will resist tooth and nail allowing the working-class to democratically control its own money and property. Still less will they allow workers to exercise democratic control over their own collective property in the joint stock companies/corporations. For that very reason, the statist, social-democratic demands for nationalisation are not only utopian and reactionary, in the era of global imperialism, they act as a distraction and a misdirection of workers. In the era of global imperialism, nationalisation, i.e. control of socialised capital by the capitalist nation state, is utopian and reactionary. It requires, at least, statisation by a much larger, multinational state, for example, the EU.

But, the idea that even such statisation represents control by workers is a dangerous delusion, as Marx and Engels describe. It represents only a more centralised and effective control of the workers' collective capital, as a means of depriving the workers of that control.

The ruling class, as a class of owners of fictitious-capital, have, therefore, become a fetter on the further development of capital itself, just as previously, the monopoly ownership of private industrial capital, in the 19th century, had become a fetter on its development, and was burst asunder, as those private industrial capitalists were expropriated by large-scale socialised capital.

“In one way or another, with trusts or without, the state, the official representative of capitalist society, is [finally] constrained to take over the direction of production. This necessity for conversion into state property first appears in the big communication organizations: the postal service, telegraphs and railways.” (p 358-9)

But, as noted above, it is an indication of the overripe conditions, and failure of the labour movement to assert its rightful democratic control over its own collective property, itself a result of the failure of its political leadership to address that property question, which means that the era of “nationalisation” has, now, also, been eclipsed by history. In the early 1980's, as the era of social-democracy peaked, its failure to address that property question and carry through to the rational conclusion the proposals for industrial democracy, led to it being rolled back. It was not just the usual to and fro between a more progressive social-democracy and conservative social-democracy, but a dynamic in which social-democracy as a whole, ate itself and a growing petty-bourgeois mass asserted itself by utilising its numbers, at the polls, to turn the clock backwards 200 years.