Part 11- Burnham Facing Reality In The Era of The Gamblers, (3) Tilting At Windmills
What does Burnham mean when he says that he wants to negotiate a deal with the EU that would give voters the Brexit they voted for? James O'Brien constantly challenges those who support/ed Brexit to spell out exactly what Brexit it was they voted for, and, of course, most of them cannot give an answer, and those that do, simply show that the reason one person voted for it, is not the same as that of others who voted for it. The idea that the debate is being “reopened” is, of course, nonsense, because no one has ever stopped discussing it for the last ten years, and could not have done otherwise, because each day that goes by shows how ludicrous it was, and why it needs to be reversed.
For Burnham to talk about negotiating the Brexit that people voted for is, then, multiply, nonsense because even those that voted for Brexit have any number of different visions of what they thought they were voting for. And, as I pointed out at the time, and as has become obvious since, whatever vision of Brexit they had, none of them was ever going to happen, because they were, and are, impossible. Many of them were not even voting, in that referendum, solely on the question of Brexit or the EU. They were using it to vote against Cameron/Osborn and their policies of austerity, implemented with the aid of the Liberals, after 2010. Many, more were simply using it as a proxy for stopping immigration, and a large part of them, for also expressing their deep-seated racism and bigotry, not just limited to stopping immigration, but also seeking the “repatriation” of “migrants”, by which they really meant, anyone who was not white.
So, exactly which of those reactionary visions of Brexit, does Burnham think that he is going to champion? But, more importantly, in 2015, when Corbyn became Labour Leader, with the help of around 250,000+ new, young, pro-EU members, he was forced by that reality, in 2016, to suppress his own long-standing economic-nationalist ideology, and ride the wave of that, pro-EU movement. In 2016, despite the revision of history, Corbyn did go out and do lots of events promoting Labour's pro-Remain position. The media, of course, did not report it, because they wanted to deny him and Labour any publicity, and were more interested in the kitchen sink drama going on in the Conservative Party between Cameron and Bojo, Gove et al, not to mention that surrounding the likes of Farage that the media had feted uncritically for the previous 20 years, as it transformed news reporting into simply sensationalised entertainment, and cult of celebrity.
Corbyn's weakness, in 2016, which was manifest later, was not that he allowed his, old, anti-EEC, economic-nationalist agenda to win out, but that he tried to cosy-up to the Blair-Right wing of the Labour Party, as it sought to undermine him at every step, and remove him. The Labour Right have always understood the concept of revolutionary defeatism when it comes to their fight against the Left in the Party, even if it results in the defeat of Labour at the polls. They put their class loyalty to the ruling-class above their loyalty to the party, every time. Just look at the role of the SDP, for example. Corbyn, in trying to accommodate the Labour Right, appointed Blair-Right former Minister, Alan Johnson, to head up Labour's Referendum campaign. Johnson who the media were promoting as a future Labour Leader, able to walk on water, of course, promptly disappeared from sight during the referendum campaign.
Corbyn was, of course, right not to give the neo-liberal EU 10/10 when asked, although it was clearly a trap, and his high positive score of 7/10 has been used against him, afterwards as supposedly some indication of how his old position affected his role during the campaign. Alan Johnson, who was supposed to lead Labour's campaign, but who was like a ghost through it all, showed his face afterwards, of course, to blame it on Corbyn! But, the facts show different. During 2016, Labour continued to attract large numbers of those new, young, pro-EU members, and millions more of them as voters.
The polling done by John Curtice and others shows that, the percentage of those that voted Labour under Ed Miliband, in 2015, who voted Remain, was around 65%. But, the percentage of those that voted Labour, under Corbyn, in 2017, who voted Remain, in 2016, is much higher. It is estimated at between 70-74%.
Key Estimates by Source
- British Election Study (BES). Wave 16 of the British Election Study (collected between 24 May and 18 June 2019 from a sample of 37,959 respondents) found that 68% of 2017 Labour voters voted to Remain in 2016.
- House of Commons Library. An analysis published by the House of Commons Library on 23 June 2017 reported that 71% of 2017 Labour voters voted Remain, while 29% voted Leave.
- YouGov. Survey data from YouGov, cited in a BBC News report on 29 April 2019, estimated that 29% of 2017 Labour voters who participated in the referendum voted Leave, placing the Remain share at 71%.
- ComRes. Estimates from ComRes, also cited by BBC News on 29 April 2019, found that 26% of 2017 Labour voters backed Leave in 2016, implying that up to 74% voted Remain or did not vote in the referendum.
Breakdown by Constituency Type
- According to the British Election Study findings published on 17 October 2019, a majority of 2017 Labour voters backed Remain across all types of constituencies:
- Remain-voting constituencies. In Labour-held seats that voted Remain in 2016, 76% of 2017 Labour voters had voted Remain.
- Leave-voting constituencies. In Labour-held seats that voted Leave in 2016, 60% of 2017 Labour voters had voted Remain.
- Strongly Leave-voting constituencies. Even in seats where the overall Leave vote exceeded 60%, 57% of 2017 Labour voters had voted Remain.
In other words, Corbyn's Labour in 2017, not only won over large numbers of voters in total, compared to 2015 under Ed Miliband, and not only secured 40% of the vote, it also won over a large number of those Remainers that had voted for other parties, in 2015, i.e. primarily Liberals, Greens, Plaid and SNP. So, when Burnham talks about negotiating a Brexit deal of the kind that people voted for in 2016, what about that large majority, between 70-74% of Labour voters, who in 2016, did not vote for Brexit at all! Why does he, like Starmer continue to ignore us, and instead continues to engage in a Quixotic endeavour to win over the votes of the reactionary petty-bourgeoisie?
