Herein lies the material basis of the different interests which are represented by Libertarianism/Classical Liberalism and neoliberalism/conservative social-democracy. Neoliberalism has been described by some on the Left as emerging, in the 1980 under Thatcher and Reagan, as an ideology based on rolling back the state, and giving free play to market forces. But, it has, in fact, never been that. That ideology is the ideology of the Classical Liberal/Libertarian, not the Neoliberal/conservative social-democrat.
The confusion arises precisely because of the nature of the Conservative Party, in Britain, and the Republican Party, in the US. Both these parties are parties whose membership and voter base is comprised of the petty-bourgeoisie, but whose upper echelons and parliamentary agenda has been dominated, and necessarily determined, by the interests of the ruling-class, i.e. the owners of fictitious-capital, and consequently, the interests of large-scale industrial capital, as refracted through them.
The conservative social-democratic wing of the party represented current reality, whilst its reactionary, petty-bourgeois wing represented an unachievable fantasy of turning the clock back to the days of the small state, small scale, private capitals, free market competition and so on. It was, and is, an unachievable fantasy for all the reasons previously described. Firstly, large-scale, state-monopoly capital, i.e. imperialist capital, is not an aberration or something imposed from outside, but is the inevitable (and progressive) consequence of the very free market competition the petty-bourgeois Liberal advocates. The extension of that – the creation of larger, multinational states in place of the nation state – is just as inevitable.
But what has been seen clearly, as a result of Brexit, is that when this reality is witnessed, when separating from the EU, to restore the “sovereignty” of the nation-state does not result in the promised benefits, but, instead, results in an accelerated economic decline, a reduction in actual sovereignty, as opposed to the fantasy of the abstract idea of sovereignty, the petty-bourgeois mindset simply believes that the abstract principle has not yet been implemented. Brexit could work they argue, but it has not been properly carried through. Its why I thought, in 2016, when Corbyn argued that Article 50 should be immediately invoked, he was right, though I suspect my reasoning was different to his.
Had Article 50 been immediately invoked in 2016, the Conservative government would have been forced to confront its own division, sharply. It would have meant having to implement the kind of “No Deal” Brexit that Theresa May, later, and emptily, threatened the EU with, that Bojo blustered about, but also knew he could not implement, and that the Faragists now claim they would implement. In short, a demand to implement Article 50, immediately, in 2016, would have cut through all of the “cakeist” fantasy and hypocrisy of the following ten years.
It would have done so, because that fantasy of the Faragists, which has enabled them to present a typical “stab in the back” narrative over all that time, of a “No Deal” Brexit, would have led to economic catastrophe, and chaos, as I noted at the time. Better to have ripped off the plaster, at that time, than let it fester a for a further ten years. Either the catastrophe caused by such a “No Deal”, “True Brexit”, in 2016, would have laid bare the fantasy, and destroyed Farage, Bojo, Mogg and co, along with it, resulting in some kind of rapid, negotiated re-entry into the EU, saving us ten years of agony, or, more likely, the immediate response to just invoking Article 50, and prospect of a “No Deal” Brexit would have been so severe that Brexit would never have happened. Some means of annulling the invocation of Article 50, would have been found.
