Thursday, 19 November 2026

Anti-Duhring, Part III – Socialism, II – Theoretical - Part 34

In the 1980's, because the working-class was misled by its political leadership – not just as the crisis unfolded, but in the ideas it had been fed for nearly a century before – it inevitably went down to defeat, because it was fighting on the wrong terrain. Where the bourgeoisie, in its revolution, never had any doubt over its ownership and control of its private property, the working-class did, because its own political leaders did not, themselves, understand the social revolution that had already taken place in the later 19th century – the expropriation of the expropriators – as socialised capital burst asunder the fetters imposed by the monopoly of privately owned capital.

Rather like the theological catastrophists and End-Timers, who revere the Book of Revelations, and interpret it as a set of signs of an Armageddon to come, so the ideological catastrophists look for similar signs of apocalypse for the capitalist system. Both fail to recognise that what they see as prediction of an approaching catastrophe is, in fact, a description of events that have already long since taken place.

Engels, himself, sets out the facts in respect to the Book of Revelations, which, by that time, were already known. The contents of the Revelations was a description of events in typically mystical form, presenting a common meme of the time that the Emperor Nero was going to return. The numerological reference to 666 has been shown to simply be a reference to Nero, emphasised by its presentation in other documents as 616, the difference being the translation into Hebrew or Greek. Yet, despite the fact that all of this has been known for more than 200 years, a description of events that happened 2000 years ago is still presented by Endtimers and other religious fantasists as being a prophecy of the apocalypse to come.

The same is true of their ideological/political equivalents. On the one hand, a look at the writings of Libertarians/Anarcho-Capitalists, going back to Mises and Hayek, shows their disdain not just for the organised working-class, but for the social-democracy that emerged as a consequence of the development of large-sale, socialised capital. Just as much as the catastrophists on the Left, the Libertarians see the existence of large-scale socialised capital as an abomination, and look for signs of its collapse. The only difference is that the Libertarians see that crisis as lifting the veil on the pernicious role of monopoly and of the role of the interventionist state, so that capitalism can return to its true form, as a society of small, privately owned firms, each engaged in free competition.

The Libertarians, in their writings, frequently describe the US, for example, as “socialist”, and when the financial crash of 2008 occurred, it was portrayed as confirming all of their warnings of such a catastrophe resulting from the interference of the state, and its role in destroying the currency, via the actions of the Federal Reserve. Its reflection came in the rise of the Tea Party. In reality, the Libertarians are simply the ideological representatives of the reactionary petty-bourgeoisie and its individualism. As I have noted before, that petty-bourgeois, individualistic mindset – basically of the peasant – is also highly visible in the realm of the financial market and commodity market traders.

The petty bourgeois commodity producer or trader has always hated the large, socialised capitals for the simple reason that they cannot compete with them. The only way for them to survive, in so far as they are in competition, is to accept a precarious existence, to work themselves all hours of the day, and to expect any labour they employ, be it family labour or wage labour, to do the same. Where they are not in competition, they often survive only by relying on that large-scale capital as a customer. They do the work that the large-scale capital no longer sees as worthwhile for its own capital, but is still able to use its monopoly power to dictate terms and prices to the small supplier.

Consequently, as Engels described 150 years ago, where the large-scale industrial capital not only can easily accommodate state regulation and trades unions, but even welcome it as part of creating the stability it requires, it is anathema to the petty-bourgeoisie.

No comments: